NBC Baseball & Softball Honors
| 2023 Softball | ||
| NBC Offensive Players of the Year: Delaney Maynard - Eastwood | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Kaylin Shields - Genoa | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Kaylin Shields (G) Cassie Kieper (Ea) | Maddie Milligan (El) Riley Rowe (O) |
| 1st Base | Liv Hussar (R) | Kynzie Science (El) |
| 2nd Base | Mariela Garcia (El) | Grace Kingery (Ea) |
| 3rd Base | Ary Bond (R) | Jessie Materni (L) |
| Shortstop | Kate Keiffer (El) | Emersen Bickel (G) |
| Catcher | Delaney Maynard (Ea) | Maddie Bronowski (G) |
| Outfield | Jessyca Smith (Ea) Abbie Allison (El) Scarlett Williams (R) | Lily Escobedo (Ea) Janelle Brooks (O) Amijah Poole (F) |
| Utility | Kali Bedford (L) | Ady Bowe (Ea) |
| DH | Katie Oestreich (Ea) | Alexis Etchie (O) |
| 2023 Baseball | ||
| NBC Offensive Player of the Year: Case Boos - Eastwood | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Andrew Badenhop - Eastwood | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Andrew Badenhop (Ea) Bodde Simon (O) | Ethan Rapp (Ea) Jackson Yerkes (R) |
| 1st Base | Jordan Pickerel (Ea) | Brandon Swope (R) |
| 2nd Base | Alex Williams (R) | Colton Woodward (Ea) |
| 3rd Base | Allen Sterling (El) | Evan Millner (G) |
| Shortstop | Case Boos (Ea) | Tucker Hunsberger (O) |
| Catcher | Ty O'Brien (O) | Gavin Kohlhofer (L) |
| Outfield | Jackson Bauer (Ea) Logan Walder (R) Hayden Wickard (El) | Myles Lowe (L) Landon Murray (El) Nate Wagner (L) Alex Spencer (G) |
| Utility | Drew Tajblik (L) | Brady Belegrin (G) |
| DH | Tristan Schuerman (Ea) | Luke Armbruster (El) |
| Second Team All-Ohio Div. II | |
| Brandon Swope (R) - 1B | |
| Coach of the Year Div. III | |
| Kevin Leahy - Eastwood | |
| First Team All-Ohio Div. III | |
| Case Boos (Ea) - Shortstop | |
| Second Team All-Ohio Div. III | |
| Jackson Bauer (Ea) - OF | |
| Honorable Mention All-Ohio Div. III | |
| Andrew Badenhop (Ea) - Utility |
| 2022 Softball | ||
| NBC Offensive Players of the Year: Delaney Maynard - Eastwood | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Lexi North - Otsego | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Cassi Kieper (Ea) Lexi North (O) | Maddie Milligan (El) Kaylin Shields (G) |
| 1st Base | Sam Sibbersen (Ea) | Riley Rowe (O) |
| 2nd Base | Evelyn Rider (O) | Grace Kingery (Ea) |
| 3rd Base | Kaitlyn Luidhardt (Ea) | Kiana Dingledine (O) |
| Shortstop | Ady Bowe (Ea) | Makayla Dingledine (O) |
| Catcher | Delaney Maynard (Ea) | Summer Berry (O) |
| Outfield | Lily Escobedo (Ea) Jessyca Smith (Ea) Abby Rymers (L) | Abby Allison (El) Marisol Bernal (F) Scarlett Williams (R) |
| Utility | Sierra Kleinmark (F) | Paige Kromenacker (R) |
| DH | Addy Boehm (L) | Ashley Gregory (O) |
| First Team All-Ohio Div. III | |
| Delaney Maynard (Ea) - INF Lexi North (O) - P | |
| Honorable Mention All-Ohio Div. III | |
| Jordan Babcock (El) - C Summer Berry (O) - C |
| 2022 Baseball | ||
| NBC Offensive Player of the Year: Seth Witt - Genoa | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Joseph Dzierwa - Otsego | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Ethan Rapp (Ea) Joseph Dzierwa (O) | Drew Tajblik (L) Jared Crozier (O) |
| 1st Base | Jordan Pickerel (Ea) | Cam Hofman (L) |
| 2nd Base | London Stuller (G) | Isaac Cherry (Ea) |
| 3rd Base | Connor Moore (L) | Andrew Badenhop (Ea) |
| Shortstop | Case Boos (Ea) | Keagan Henry (L) |
| Catcher | Michael Toiles (L) | Ty O'Brien (O) |
| Outfield | Lake Boos (Ea) Seth Witt (G) Richie Hayward (L) Aasron Miller (W) | Jackson Bauer (Ea) Lex Voska (El) Jacob Tuczynski (R) |
| Utility | Brandon Swope (R) | Bryce Sandwisch (W) |
| DH | Jackson Bauer (Ea) | Blake Steele (O) |
| First Team All-Ohio Div. III | |
| Seth Witt (G) - 1B | |
| Second Team All-Ohio Div. III | |
| Ethan Rapp (Ea) - P Case Boos (Ea) - INF |
| 2021 Softball | ||
| NBC Co-Offensive Players of the Year: Eve Sorrato - Otsego Madison Hoiles - Elmwood | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Lexi North - Otsego | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Lexi North (O) Maddie Milligan (El) | Cassi Kieper (El) Mackenzie Mickens (L) |
| 1st Base | Madison Hoiles (El) | Brooke Allen (W) |
| 2nd Base | Kensie Mareches (El) | Makayla Dingledine (O) |
| 3rd Base | Kaitlyn Luidhardt (Ea) | Araha Burgy (O) |
| Shortstop | Eve Serrato (O) | Jaylee Souder (Ea) |
| Catcher | Delaney Maynard (Ea) | Summer Berry (O) |
| Outfield | Lainey Bingham (El) Abbie Rymers (L) Caitlin Cruickshank (G) | Lilly Escobedo (Ea) Khloey Hutton (O) Jessyca Smith (Ea) |
| Utility | Lola Luderman (R) | Kenzie Jackson (L) |
| DH | Hanna Puente (F) | Lilliana Blachuta (El) |
| First Team All-Ohio Div. III | Second Team All-Ohio Div. III |
| IF - Madison Hoiles (El) P - Lexi North (O) |
C - Delany Maynard (Ea) C - Summer Berry (O) IF - Eva Serrato (O) |
| 2021 Baseball | ||
| NBC Offensive Player of the Year: Cam Hoffman - Lake | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Jaxon Delvanthal - Lake | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Jaxon Delvanthal (L) Lake Boos (Ea) | Conner Smith (O) Joe Dzierwa (O) |
| 1st Base | Seth Witt (G) | Brandon Swope (R) |
| 2nd Base | Tyler Dowell (R) | Isaac Cherry (Ea) |
| 3rd Base | Noah Dzierwa (O) | Conner Moore (L) |
| Shortstop | Tyler Saffran (L) | Hunter Allen (W) |
| Catcher | Andrew McManus (R) | Michael Tolles (L) |
| Outfield | Cam Hoffman (L) Ryan Gray (O) Aaron Miller (W) | Richie Hayward (L) Trent Bachmayer (R) Jacob Tuczynski (R) |
| Utility | Case Boos (Ea) | DJ Melter (W) |
| DH | Andrew Arntson (Ea) | Jake Emerson (G) |
| Honorable Mention All-Ohio Div. II | |
| Brandon Swope (R) | |
| Second Team All-Ohio Div. III | |
| 1B - Seth Witt (G) U/DH - Cam Hoffman (L) |
2020 Seasons cancelled due to COVID-19
| 2019 Softball | ||
| NBC Offensive Player of the Year: Carleigh Coffield - Eastwood | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Ashley Hitchcock - Eastwood | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Ashley Hitchcock (Ea) Shelby Spurlock (O) | Sara Blausey (G) Mackenzie Mickens (L) |
| 1st Base | Alissa Ray (Ea) | Kyhra Baeder (F) |
| 2nd Base | Hannah Owens (Ea) | Makenna Benshoter (El) |
| 3rd Base | Carleigh Coffield (Ea) | Araha Burgy (O) |
| Shortstop | Eve Serrato (O) | Tatum Miller (L) |
| Catcher | Maddie Recker (Ea) | Macie Wellons (W) |
| Outfield | Katelynn Marshall (W) Hannah Pierce (R) Jill Hannah (El) | Caitlin Cruickshank (G) Brynne Limes (O) Carmen Bejarano (Ea) |
| Utility | Sydni Buhrow (W) | Kenzie Jackson (L) |
| DH | Madison Hoiles (El) | Kyah Talley (F) |
| First Team All-Ohio Div. III | Second Team All-Ohio Div. III |
| IF - Madison Hoiles (El) | P - Shelby Spurlock (O) |
| 2019 Baseball | ||
| NBC Offensive Player of the Year: Harry Jackson - Lake | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Jacob Boelkens - Lake | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Jacob Boelkens (L) Austin Fouty (L) | Noah Veryser (El) Ben Gray (O) |
| 1st Base | Seth Witt (G) | Noah Hahn (Ea) |
| 2nd Base | Harry Jackson (L) | Austin Meier (O) |
| 3rd Base | David Silva Jr. (O) | Shane Pitzen (R) |
| Shortstop | Scott Mackiewicz (L) | Jonathon Duvall (El) |
| Catcher | Dawson Delventhal (L) | Tyler St. Clair (El) |
| Outfield | Jake Stewart (G) Luke Walsh (L) Taityn Rollins (W) | Cole Millhime (G) Bronson Medley (L) Trevor Bingham (El) |
| Utility | Josh Vischer (G) | Justin Pickerel (Ea) |
| DH | Dylan Gerkens (El) | Logan Reiter (R) |
| First Team All-Ohio Div. III | Second Team All-Ohio Div. III |
| IF - Harry Jackson (L) | P - Jacob Boelkens (L) |
| Honorable Mention All-Ohio Div. III | |
| David Silva (O) | |
| 2018 Softball | ||
| NBC Offensive Player of the Year: Maddy Dyer - Eastwood | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Ashley Hitchcock - Eastwood | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Ashley Hitchcock (Ea) Shelbey Spurlock (O) | Makenna Benschoter (El) Tatum Miller (L) |
| 1st Base | Alissa Ray (Ea) | Kyhra Baeder (F) |
| 2nd Base | Hannah Owens (Ea) Eve Serrato (O) | -- |
| 3rd Base | Carleigh Coffield (Ea) | Leah Rieger (O) |
| Shortstop | Maddy Dyer (Ea) | Mattison Hillard (El) |
| Catcher | Meghan Melcher (Ea) | Chy Cluck (El) |
| Outfield | Makenzie Wilson (O) Carmen Bejarano (Ea) Allison Drees (El) | Jill Hannah (El) Caitlin Cruickshank (G) Tyriana Settles (F) |
| Utility | Madison Hoiles (El) | Sydni Burow (W) |
| DH | Kayla Minich (El) | Hailey Asmus (O) |
| First Team All-Ohio Div. III | Second Team All-Ohio Div. III |
| IF - Maddy Dyer (Ea) P - Ashley Hitchcock (Ea) |
IF - Madison Hoiles (El) P - Shelby Spurlock (O) |
| 2018 Baseball | ||
| NBC Offensive Players of the Year: Cade Boos - Eastwood David Silva - Otsego | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Tyler Haas - Eastwood | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Tyler Haas (Ea) A.J. Mancini (O) | Jacob Boelkens (L) Derek Berkel (W) |
| 1st Base | Sam Witt (G) | Corey Holar (O) |
| 2nd Base | Harry Jackson (L) | Lance Sniegowski (O) |
| 3rd Base | Jake Pickerel (Ea) | Ausin Meier (O) |
| Shortstop | Ryan Jagodzinski (R) David Silva (O) | Mitchell Miller (W) |
| Catcher | Donovan Reyes (W) | Rylen Stoner (G) |
| Outfield | Cade Boos (Ea) Noah Edwards (G) Will Varner (O) | Brendan Halko (Ea) Luke Walsh (L) Ben Gray (O) |
| Utility | Justin Pickerel (Ea) | Tyler St. Clair (El) |
| DH | Scott Gabe (G) | Mike McManus (R) |
| First Team All-Ohio Div. III | |
| IF - Jake Pickerel (Ea) | |
| Honorable Mention All-Ohio Div. III | |
| Cade Boos (Ea) Noah Edwards (G) | |
| 2017 Softball | ||
| NBC Offensive Player of the Year: Alissa Ray - Eastwood | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Ashley Hitchcock - Eastwood | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Ashley Hitchcock (Ea) Shelbey Spurlock (O) | Sydnee Behlmer (L) Makenna Benschoter (El) |
| 1st Base | Alissa Ray (Ea) | Kristen Zink (L) |
| 2nd Base | Savannah Harvey (El) | Hannah Owens (Ea) |
| 3rd Base | Carleigh Coffield (Ea) | Katelynn Marshall (W) |
| Shortstop | Holly Roe (O) | Mattison Hillard (El) |
| Catcher | Maddie Recker (Ea) | Mercedes McNett (O) |
| Outfield | Meghan Melcher (Ea) Erica Smith (G) Makenzie Wilson (O) | Allison Drees (El) Cortney Babb (F) Lizzy Cook (W) |
| Utility | Rebekah Swartz (L) | Alex Talley (F) |
| DH | Macey Fix (Ea) | Paige Marsh (El) |
| First Team All-Ohio Div. III | Second Team All-Ohio Div. III |
| P - Ashley Hitchcock (Ea) | IF - Alissa Ray (Ea) C - Mercedes McNett (O) |
| Honorable Mention All-Ohio Div. III | |
| IF - Savannah Harvey (El) | |
| 2017 Baseball | ||
| NBC Offensive Player of the Year: Cody Orr - Rossford | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Jordan Bekier - Lake | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Jordan Bekier (L) Kyle Krieger (R) | Austin Berkel (W) Dollin Dewese (Ea) |
| 1st Base | Gabe Scott (G) | Corey Hollar (O) |
| 2nd Base | Lance Sniegowski (O) | Jarrod Hornyak (L) |
| 3rd Base | Jake Pickerel (Ea) | Dylan O'Quinn (L) |
| Shortstop | Cody Orr (R) | Grant Hirzel (Ea) |
| Catcher | Tyler Haas (Ea) | Donovan Reyes (W) |
| Outfield | Cade Boos (Ea) Scott Mackiewicz (L) J.T. Atkin (W) | Austin Eick (R) Brendan Halko (Ea) Kurtis Lee (G) |
| Utility | Trey Yates (F) | Shane Pitzen (R) |
| DH | Matt Bradfield (G) | Nathan Sampsell (L) |
| 2016 Softball | ||
| NBC Offensive Player of the Year: Mackenzie Albright - Eastwood | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Ashley Hitchcock - Eastwood | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Ashley Hitchcock (Ea) Makenna Benschoter (El) | Shelbey Spurlock (O) Sydnee Behlmer (L) |
| 1st Base | Alissa Ray (Ea) | Emma Materni (L) |
| 2nd Base | Savannah Harvey (El) | Chayce McQueary (G) |
| 3rd Base | Carleigh Coffield (Ea) | Mattison Hillard (El) |
| Shortstop | Mackenzie Albright (Ea) | Holly Roe (O) |
| Catcher | Maddie Recker (Ea) | Sam Hoffman (L) |
| Outfield | Alexa Schmeltz (Ea) Emilee Kunkelman (L) Lexie Rieger (O) | Cheyenne Davis (R) Alex Appelhans (Ea) Jill Hannah (El) |
| Utility | Haley Gerke (G) | Alex Talley(F) |
| DH | Macey Fix (Ea) | |
| First Team All-Ohio Div. III | Second Team All-Ohio Div. III |
| IF - MacKenzie Albright (Ea) | P - Ashley Hitchcock (Ea) |
| 2016 Baseball | ||
| NBC Offensive Player of the Year: Adam Duncan - Lake | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Trevor Solether - Elmwood | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Hunter Carson (O) Trevor Solether (El) | Eli Brown (Ea) Collin Dewese (Ea) |
| 1st Base | Jon Brown (Ea) | Ben Sauter (R) |
| 2nd Base | Jared Luther (Ea) | Tristan Roth (W) |
| 3rd Base | Jake Pickerel (Ea) | Dylan O'Quinn (L) |
| Shortstop | Cody Orr (R) | Philip Buckingham (El) |
| Catcher | Dylan Hall (El) | Tyler Haas (Ea) |
| Outfield | Adam Duncan (L) Noah Edwards (G) Cade Boos (Ea) | Lance Smith (F) Tyler Stone (El) Michael Apthorpe (G) |
| Utility | Jordan Bekier (L) | Tayte Lentz (El) |
| DH | Aaron Witt(L) | Dillon Williams (W) |
| 2015 Softball | ||
| NBC Offensive Player of the Year: | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Miranda Beschoter (El) Lea Theisen (G) | Sydnee Behlmer (L) Kylie Asmus (O) |
| 1st Base | Erica Moore (F) | Morgan Getz (Ea) |
| 2nd Base | Krista Jennings (Ea) | Olivia Myers (El) |
| 3rd Base | Alexa Schmeltz (Ea) | Kirsten Keller (R) |
| Shortstop | Rebecca Harvey (El) | Holly Roe (O) |
| Catcher | Lindsay George (El) | Emma Perry (O) |
| Outfield | Caitlin Clay (Ea) Lexie Rieger (O) Allie Kontak (L) | Erica Smith (G) Jasmine Marsh (El) Asia Settles (F) |
| Utility | Mackenzie Albright (Ea) | Hana Zollinger (W) |
| DH | Hannah Gauthier (R) | Macey Fix (Ea) Kristi Reiser (El) |
| 2015 Baseball | ||
| NBC Offensive Player of the Year: Nick Wolfe - Genoa | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Luke Rightnowar - Genoa | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Luke Rightnowar (G) Tristan Roth (W) | Hunter Carson (O) Dugan Smith (F) |
| 1st Base | Ben Sauter (R) | Jon Brown (O) |
| 2nd Base | Chris Hampton (F) | Cody Pickard (G) |
| 3rd Base | Kyle Edwards (G) | Jake Pickerel (Ea) |
| Shortstop | Connor Bowen (L) | Matt Aumiller (G) |
| Catcher | Nick Wolfe (G) | Alex LaPlante (R) |
| Outfield | Jake Wojciechowski(G) Lance Smith (F) Zak Greenlese (L) | Cade Boos (Ea) Logan Fonseca (W) Aaron Witt (L) |
| Utility | Trent Soto (O) | Todd Walters (L) |
| DH | Trevor Solether (El) | Brandon Knieriem (L) |
| Honorable Mention All-Ohio Div. III | |
| C - Nick Wolfe (G) |
| 2014 Softball | ||
| NBC Offensive Player of the Year: Cassidy Rolf - Eastwood | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Madeline Phillips - Woodmore | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Madeline Phillips (W) Miranda Benschoter (El) | Mandi Longeway (R) Sydnee Behlmer (L) |
| 1st Base | Kelly Swope (R) | Morgan Getz (Ea) |
| 2nd Base | Olivia Myers (El) | Krista Jennings (Ea) |
| 3rd Base | Cassidy Rolf (Ea) | Lindsay George (El) |
| Shortstop | Rebecca Harvey (El) | acKenzie Albright (Ea) |
| Catcher | Margo Jackson (R) | Anna Rahrig (Ea) |
| Outfield | Madison Arnold (El) Kylie Asmus (O) Allie Kontak (L) | Marissa Tudor (Ea) Maddie York (R) Erica Moore (F) |
| Utility | Samantha Shirling (Ea) | Emily Edwards (G) |
| DH | Kristie Reiser (El) | Ciara Albright (G) |
| First Team All District Div. II | |
| P - Samantha Shirling (Ea) IF - Cassidy Rolf (Ea) |
OF - Marissa Tudor (Ea) |
| District Coach of the Year Div. III | |
| Matt Hoiles - Elmwood | |
| First Team All District Div. III | |
| P - Miranda Benshotter (El) P - Madeline Phillips (W) |
C - Margo Jackson (R) IF - Rebecca Harvey (El) |
| Honorable Mention All-Ohio Div. III | |
| IF - Savannah Harvey (El) | |
| Second Team All-Ohio Div. II | |
| Cassidy Rolf (Ea) | |
| First Team All-Ohio Div. III | Second Team All-Ohio Div. III |
| P - Madeline Phillips (W) IF - Rebecca Harvey (El) |
C - Margo Jackson (R) |
| 2014 Baseball | ||
| NBC Offensive Player of the Year: Connor Bowen (L) | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Jayce Vancena (L) | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Jayce Vancena (L) Luke Rightnowar (G) | Todd Walters (L) Tristan Roth (W) |
| 1st Base | Logan Scott (G) | Hunter Abell(F) |
| 2nd Base | Chris Hampton (F) | Cody Witt(L) |
| 3rd Base | Jake Schmeltz (Ea) | Tyler Stone (El) |
| Shortstop | Connor Bowen (L) | Ryan Mang (Ea) |
| Catcher | Nick Wolfe (G) | Joe Brown (O) |
| Outfield | Casey Gose (G) Jacob Wise (El) Eli Brown (Ea) | Adam Duncan (L) Robby Crotty (F) Jake Matwiejczyk (W) |
| Utility | Noah Asmus (O) | Kaleb Bemis (F) |
| DH | Anthony Pratt (L) | Mat Drown (Ea) |
| First Team All-Ohio Div. III | |
| P - Jayce Vancena (L) |
| 2013 Softball | ||
| NBC Offensive Player of the Year: Alena Gabel - Eastwood | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Miranda Banshoter - Elmwood | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Miranda Benschoter (El) Whitney Foster (Ea) | Hannah Gauthier (R) Kylie Asmus (O) |
| 1st Base | Kelly Swope (R) | Diana Bushman (Ea) |
| 2nd Base | Katie Bottesch (El) | Tayler Bowen (O) |
| 3rd Base | Rebecca Harvey (El) | Cassidy Rolf (Ea) |
| Shortstop | Kayla Encalado (L) | Mackenzie Albright (Ea) |
| Catcher | Margo Jackson (R) | Anna Rahrig (Ea) |
| Outfield | Ashlyn Roberts (F) Alena Gabel (Ea) Madison Arnold (El) | Allie Kontak (L) Brynn Skilliter (G) Maddie York (R) |
| Utility | Madeline Phillips (W) | Brittany George (El) |
| DH | Olivia Myers (El) | Mandi Longeway (R) |
| Second Team All-Ohio Div. III | |
| OF - Alena Gabel (Ea) |
| 2013 Baseball | ||
| NBC Offensive Player of the Year: Ryan Reed - Rossford | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Ryan Smoyer - Otsego | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Ryan Smoyer (O) Jayce Vancena (L) | Grant Peters (Ea) Jordan Luther (Ea) |
| 1st Base | Casey Kitchen (F) | |
| 2nd Base | Ryan Mang (Ea) | Casey Gose (G) |
| 3rd Base | Noah Asmus (R) | Zach Brossia (W) |
| Shortstop | Nate Hackworth (O) | Skyler Dierker (Ea) |
| Catcher | Zach Coffield (Ea) | Nick Wolfe (G) |
| Outfield | Colin Austin (O) Brad Ackerman (L) Drake Johnson (O) | Zack Irick (El) Jake Wise (El) Jake Wojciechowski (G) |
| Utility | Ryan Reed (R) | Zach Foster (El) |
| DH | Alex Hayes(G) | Hunter Abell (F) |
| 2012 Softball | ||
| NBC Offensive Players of the Year: Brittany George - Elmwood Margo Jackson - Rossford | ||
| NBC Pitchers of the Year: Madeline Phillips - Woodmore Whitney Foster - Eastwood | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Madeline Phillips (W) Whitney Foster (Ea) | Kylie Asmus (O) Miranda Benschoet (El) |
| 1st Base | Courtney Rolf (Ea) | Kelly Swope (R) |
| 2nd Base | Jessica Young(Ea) | Katie Jensen (G) |
| 3rd Base | Cassidy Rolf (Ea) | Megan Schnell (L) |
| Shortstop | Brittany George (El) | Hannah Hirzel (Ea) Kayla Encalado (L) |
| Catcher | Margo Jackson (R) | Tori Hillard (El) |
| Outfield | Sierra Beckford (El) Ally Gabel (Ea) Abby Stahl (R) | Brynn Skilliter (G) Ashley Roberts (F) Brittany Mondragon (W) Hallie Adair (L) |
| Utility | Whitney Striff (El) | Mackenzie Hoyles (G) Katie Bottesch (El) |
| First Team All District Div. III | |
| P - Whitney Foster (Ea) P - Madeline Phillips (W) OF - Ally Gabel (Ea) OF - Tori Hillard (El) |
IF - Brittany George (El) IF - Megan Schnell (L) IF - Cassidy Rold (Ea) |
| Honorable Mention All-Ohio Div. II | |
| C - Margo Jackson (R) | |
| First Team All-Ohio Div. III | Second Team All-Ohio Div. III |
| IF - Brittany George (El) | P - Whitney Foster (Ea) |
| Honorable Mention All-Ohio Div. III | |
| P - Madeline Phillips (W) | IF - Megan Schnell (L) |
| 2012 Baseball | ||
| NBC Offensive Player of the Year: Jeff Vanscoder - Elmwood | ||
| NBC Pitcher of the Year: Nick Vespi - Eastwood | ||
| Position | First Team All-NBC | Second Team All-NBC |
| Pitcher | Nick Vespi (Ea) Jake Materni (L) | P-Conlan Varty (El) Jayce Vancena (L) |
| 1st Base | Casey Kitchen (F) | Nate Downs (O) |
| 2nd Base | Ryan Mang (Ea) | Dustin Pepper (O) |
| 3rd Base | ||
| Shortstop | Nathan Hackworth (O) | John Sandwisch (W) |
| Catcher | Zach Coffield (Ea) | Trey Marsh (El) |
| Outfield | Josh Tantari (L) Jeff Vanscoder (El) Corey Hotmer (L) | Zack Irick (El) Michael Jarosz (R) Drake Johnson (O) |
| Utility | Hunter Donald(O) Casey Gose (G) | |
| DH | Kris Hayward (Ea) | Zak Keels (F) |
2023 | 2022 | 2021 | 2020 | 2019 | 2018 | 2017 | 2016 | 2015 | 2014 | 2013 | 2012
